TESTING LATE DEVONIAN EXTINCTION HYPOTHESES
Both classes of models are catastrophic: large-igneous province volcanism and asteroid or comet impact. A single impact model can be ruled out, as its predicted effects do not match those of the extinction pulses seen in the late Frasnian. An episodic global-winter model would, but those effects can be produced by both the catastrophic volcanism and multiple impacts models. Alternative models suggest that both catastrophic volcanism and multiple impacts may trigger a global greenhouse-induced temperature increase, a predicted effect that does not match the empirical data. However, if both of those mechanisms are shifted back in time to produce lag-time models of short-term global temperature increase and then rapid temperature drops as the anomalous greenhouse interval collapsed, then both produce effects that do match the empirical data.
To definitively choose among the several model predictions two critical data are needed: (1) an accurate Late Devonian temperature curve, and (2) an accurate radiometric date on the Frasnian-Famennian boundary.