POST PERMO-TRIASSIC TERRESTRIAL VERTEBRATE RECOVERY: SOUTHWESTERN UNITED STATES
Comparisons were made between the Holbrook Member fauna of the Moenkopi, a unit best characterized as a low-sinuosity medium- to coarse-grained fluvial deposit, and each of four Chinle stratigraphic units, representing fluvial settings from sandy low-sinuosity to muddy high-sinuosity. Three metrics were applied: generic and familial taxonomic diversity and guild diversity, these were compared by rarefaction. Units of extraordinary preservation in the Chinle – the so-called “blue layers” – were removed from the analysis. Generic-level and guild rarefaction show similar trends, with two biostratigraphically younger Chinle faunas appearing slightly less diverse than two older Chinle faunas and the Holbrook Member Moenkopi fauna. At the familial-level the same trend is seen among the Chinle faunas, but the Holbrook fauna plots nearer to the younger Chinle faunas. In all tests the Holbrook Member fauna is within the variation seen in Chinle faunas.
The results of our study contradict those of earlier studies which claim that biodiversity in Triassic communities was not fully recovered for 15-30 million years after the end of the Permian. Instead, our analysis suggests that by the early Anisian (6 Ma after the P-T extinction) biodiversity had reached levels comparable to those seen in the Late Triassic. This brings terrestrial vertebrate recovery more in line with the 4-10 million years it took for recovery in the marine realm.