CONFLICTING BODY-SIZE TRENDS ACROSS THE PLIO–PLEISTOCENE MOLLUSCAN TURNOVER EVENT IN THE WESTERN ATLANTIC DESPITE SUBSEQUENT NUTRIENT LIMITATION

Preliminary data indicate between the latest Pliocene and recent approximately 85% of bivalves and 90% of gastropod species in Florida and the Atlantic Coastal Plain became extinct, with high levels of origination resulting in similar total species richness in the region today. We expected this event may have impacted molluscan body size as body size in mollusks is generally correlated with nutrient availability and primary productivity, which decreased following the Pliocene closure of the Central American Seaway.

Previous work indicated small body size is associated with extinction survival during this event in both bivalves and gastropods. Where all extant and Pliocene members of surviving bivalve clades have been compared, these have also declined in size; comparable studies of all extant and Pliocene members of gastropod clades have not yet, however, been undertaken.

We investigated 3 families of gastropods of differing ecology with both high turnover and at least one boundary-crossing lineage in order to assess the impact of the turnover event on each clade’s body size. These were the predatory Conidae, the herbivorous Tegulidae, and the suspension-feeding Turritellidae. These had approximately 65%, 75%, and 90% extinction, respectively, with modern­ diversity at 110%, 100%, and 10% of their respective Pliocene species richness in the region.

Despite high levels of turnover, we found no general pattern of body-size change associated with the event either within clades or among boundary-crossing lineages. While many of the largest species of Conidae and Turritellidae did become extinct, this was balanced by the loss of smaller-bodied species, while the Tegulidae increased in size. Among ancestor-descendant pairs, 1 turritellid decreased in size while 1 remained unchanged, 4 Conidae decreased in size while 2 increased in size, and 1 tegulid increased in size.

These data suggest that for gastropods there were complex interactions between ecology, extinction, origination, and body-size evolution associated with this event and that a more phylogenetically-diverse dataset is needed to determine whether generalizable patterns exist which may be used to predict responses to future environmental change.